This case study involves many interesting things that take place. It all starts with a short story of the author's take on the case that will follow and how they too felt bad about the way the began to feel when they had to take care of one of their terminally ill parents. The case begins with Kate who is talking with her counselor. She is upset because she is having to now take care of her mother who is terminaly ill and cannot take care of herself. She begins by saying "It's not that I don't want to take care of her; it's that I don't have the time." Kate feels that her mother is somewhat intruding into her personal life and she is having to put her own life on hold to take care of her mother. Kate is almost to the point of resentment towards her mother because of this and it is really starting to deminish thier mother daughter relationship. The therapist then asks her a question that really brings it all into perspective. She asks "Do you think your mother never resented taking care of you?" This really brought the situation into another light for Kate. She thought about all the times that her mother would wait on her hand and foot while she was younger and ill and how her mother never used to show that it bothered her one bit. Then she looked at her own children and thought about the same situation. Kate felt that sometimes she did resent her children for having to take care of them when they were sick and she then realized that her mother probably did as well but what makes a good mother is to hide things such as those and due the duty of a parent.
Kate is running into larger issues here though. She feels that she is not receiving proper social support for her efforts with her mother. She is looking past some of the invisible supports that are there though. Althought she feelst that she is not receiving recognition for her efforts she really is but in a subtle manner. Kate mentions that she really enjoyed her conversations with her mother and this could be considered part of her recognition. Without Kate, her mother may be even worse off and Kate would not be able to have these conversations with her. Although Kate needs more recogntion than she is getting in order for her to feel that her efforts are not going unseen. The relational satisfaction between Kate and her mother is at a alltime low as well. Kate's mother is receiving all of the pleasure and enjoyment out of the interactions while Kate is having to change her at times and dress her. Kate is involving a lot of external manifestations towards her counselor and this is a vital part of her own mental and physical health. Without this support system Kate may have the urge to just let go and stop caring for her mother. In turn this will cause her to lose the small relationship she has left with her mother and perhaps never gain this back. It seems almost of dire importance to keep what they have going so that it is not lost forever. Kate eventually comes around and see's that her efforts are not being waisted and this begins to mend her and her mothers relationship.
I think that everyone gets over whelmed with life. In this story she is overwhelmed and not getting support from her immediate family, and her extended family. No one thinks about helping her and understanding her point of view. I personally can understand this as I am sure that many single parents can also. When life is overwhelming support whether invisible or not may not be enough. Everyone wants to be appreciated and understood. I do like how you mentioned the invisible support and not seeing the good times. I think we all need to look for the positive in all relationships.
ReplyDeleteI agree with KRoberts' comment about the invisible support. Kate does not want invisible support she wants visible recognition from her mother. She is still a child at heart when it comes to being with her mother and she needs to hear praise and appreciation from her mother for the amazing support she is giving to her mother and her family of her own. I think you are not understanding the pain Kate is going through and asking her to be stoic about her tough situation. -Cezanne Sanchez
ReplyDeleteIn this case study Kate is definitely feeling a lack of social support in reflection with her care taking of her mother. I think it is interesting that you point out Kate's mother is receiving all of the emotional support and relational satisfaction. It is important that Kate realized that her care taking and time spent with her mother is not being wasted. At the end of the case study Kate confirms with herself that her time is being well spent which builds upon the relationship between Kate and her mother.
ReplyDeleteI dont have any children, but I am sure that it is hard taking care of them sometimes. I couldnt imagine having to take care of my Mother though, as she has always taken care of me. I guess the biggest key in this case is that people need support whether they show it or not.
ReplyDeleteI think it was key that Kate got the support she needed from her therapist. She was able to reframe the situation and realize it was honorable to return the love and care her mother gave her.
ReplyDeleteGood job-
Melanie Geddes
This was a tough case to read. I was originally going to analyze this case but it just hit too close to home. I think Kate's support she got from her therapist was important and good but I think that she'll need to share the weight of taking care of her mother with her brother moving forward. She also needs to find some outlet for herself to be independent, something for her.
ReplyDeleteIt's super hard for the parent child role to be reversed. I've watched it happen first hand and its hard to imagine the feelings from both sides without actually having to be one of the people. Children don't realize how much they depend on their parents until their parents can't be that person for them anymore. Well done.
ReplyDeleteThis case was so difficult for me to read, I saw this happen with my mom and grandmother at the end of last year before my grandmother passed away. You're absolutely right when you mention the relational satisfaction between Kate and her mother being at a very low point. Realizing that your mother is never again going to "mother you" is one of the most difficult things we have to go through, since our relationship with our parents is (usually) our longest running one. Great blog!
ReplyDelete